Methodological individualism reconsidered springerlink. Hobbes was critical of the assumptions of scholastic philosophers, whose evidence for human nature was based upon aristotelian metaphysics and cartesian observation, as. In this article i distinguish a number of versions of methodological individualism that differ significantly in. Methodological individualism and rational choice oxford. Defenders of methodological individualism generally claim that it is. Three theories of individualism philip schuyler bishop abstract this thesis traces versions of the theory of individualism by three major theorists, john locke, john stuart mill and john dewey, as they criticize existing social, cultural, economic, legal and military conditions of their times. The political theory of possessive individualism hobbes. In what follows i discuss and hopefully render harmless a doctrine which has a very long ancestry, has constantly reappeared in the history of sociology and still appears to haunt the scene. This orientation, a form of methodological individualism, is one that grounds social theory in a theory of individual action. However, the term is rarely defined with adequate precision and some crucial ambiguities are explored in this article. Hobbes methodological individualism, completely assumed by the neoclassical school as a way of explaining the economic world, understands the individual separated from the social organization. Lionel robbins methodological individualism in the light of the philosophy of science thiago dumont oliveira abstract this paper draws on the debate among philosophers of science in. The first law of nature holds that every man should seek peace and preserve it and if he cannot obtain it he must defend himself by all means including war. Methodological individualism in ecology james justusy methodological individualism has a long, successful, and controversial track record in the social sciences.
Lionel robbins methodological individualism in the light. The positive political economy of individualism and. Inspired by this hobbesian approach, methodological individualists. The tension between methodological individualism and holism.
In developing his moral and political philosophy, hobbes assumes the methodological approach of deductive reasoning, combining mathematics and the mechanics of science to formulate his ideas on human nature. Methodological individualism criticizing and superseding possibilities 187 the term methodological individualism first appeared in schumpeters theory of economic development17, p. T he n ature of r ati on al c hoice b rief h istory although the origins of rational choice theory may be a bit murky, its modern roots stem from the age of reason. Methodological individualism sage research methods. There is a long tradition in the social sciencesgoing back to hobbes and continued through j. Crudely put, methodological individualism is the thesis that good socialscientific explanations should refer solely to facts about individuals and their interactions, not to any higherlevel social entities, properties, or causes. It is common to categorize social scientific theories as either individualistic or holistic, and to assume that they are opposites. The meanings of individualism by steven lukes we shall begin with the fact that the same word, or the same concept in most cases, means very different things when used by differently situated persons. This article discusses the concept of methodological individualism and rational choice mirc. Its pivotal intellectual position was secured in thomas hobbes leviathan 1651. According to hobbes, the natural equality of human beings means that all have the ability to kill one another. Mac pherson s lectures on political thought at the university of toronto will be extremely delighted to find within the pages of this book a more coherent.
Methodological individualism reconsidered in what follows i discuss and hopefully render harmless a doctrine which has a very long ancestry, has constantly reappeared in the history of sociology and still appears to haunt the scene. Coleman 1990 stated that, in his own variant of methodological individualism, the interaction among individuals is seen to result in emergent phenomena at the system level p. Hobbes and tocqueville on individualism, equality, and centralized administration by grant webster there exists a connection between hobbes and tocqueville has thus far been inadequately explored in the academic literature. In the recent methodological individualismholism debate on explanation, there has been considerable focus on what reasons methodological holists may advance in support of their position. The political theory of possessive individualism hobbes to locke. Watkinsthat insists that explanations of social phenomena must derive from the. Contexts of definition, theory and the new discourse of problem solving the examples of holism in the sciences are considered in detail in a separate article see. Sixthly, even after contract, individuals retain the liberty of thought, belief, education, art, literature, etc. Hobbess quite doubtful reputation does not stem from his rejection of aristotles philosophy but rather from his insight into the deadly consequences of equality. There are different versions of both doctrines, and some versions combine elements from both. The methodological implications of the schutzparsons debate. Methodological individualism and holism in political science lse. Meanings of methodological individualism geoffrey m. References to hobbess works follow the pattern used in my hobbess system of ideas, hutchinson, london, 1965.
Hobbess leviathan, part 5 mary midgley opinion the. This neat picture is not so much wrong as too simple. The changing face of methodological individualism annual. Macpherson was a canadian philosopher who influenced quite a few young scholars in the 1970s in north america and great britain. Selfadvancement would occur most successfully if left unimpeded, just as classical physics had it. Some readers might think that such a stance requires one to give up ethical individualism, but it does. Hobbes and tocqueville on individualism, equality, and. Applied to human social life, hobbes believed, the laws of motion would at first lead to conflict, whereupon human intelligence would. A closely related view, sometimes called ontological individualism, is the thesis that social or historical groups, processes, and events are nothing more than complexes of individuals and individual actions. Crawford brough macphersons the political theory of possessive individualism. Hobbes methodological individualism, completely assumed by the neoclassical school as a way of explaining the economic world, understands the individual. The first use of the term methodological individualism in english was again by schumpeter in his 1909 quarterly journal of economics paper, on the concept of social value see. Its record in ecology is much shorter but proving as successful and controversial with socalled individualbased models.
Methodological individualism is the view that phenomena can only be understood by examining how they result from the motivations and actions of individual agents. The subsequent consideration of the different meanings of methodological individualism is confined to the period after the second world war, when its use became prominent. A group of thinkers trying to recover the holistic sense of what is known today as social sciences emerged in scotland during the xvii century. The same orientation was shared by social and political philosophers of the 17th, 18th, and 19th centuries such as hobbes, smith, locke, rous. Of course, part of hayeks motivation for endorsing methodological individualism and demanding that socialscientific explanations specify a mechanism at the actiontheoretic level is that he wants to emphasize the limitations of the individuals actors perspective. Max webers basic aim of his interpretative sociology was a methodological foundation of sociology that makes it possible to grasp the subjective motives and intentions of the actors.
Methodological individualism and holism in political. Hobbes is an intellectual revolutionary who undertook nothing less than a fundamental regrounding of philosophy, one comparable in its radicality with the new beginning proposed by descartes. The individualism of hobbes was widely taken to be the application of the laws of motion to human life. Methodological individualism precludes explanations that appeal to social factors that cannot in turn be individualistically explained.
Methodological individualism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Possessive individualism was widely hailed as a pathbreaking interpretation of seventeenthcentury english. Add one setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your universitys proxy server configure custom proxy use this if. However, the idea of methodological individualism as a fundamental principle of analyzing social occurrences and happenings has been proposed by. Their methodological criticisms have a tendency, however, to devolve into repudiations of moral individualism as such. Hobbess theory of the social contract is an early example of a rational choice. Methodological individualism is a philosophical system that privileges the individual as sovereign. In the social sciences, methodological individualism is the principle that subjective individual. Mirc strives to explain international events by positing individuals, states, or substate actors, with fixed preferences and identities, who rationally adjust their beliefs and strategies in response to the information they receive and the strategies pursued by other actors. Over and above his opposition to methodological individualism in philosophy, hegel also argued against. Meanings of methodological individualism geoffrey hodgson.
Those of us who have had the good fortune to be exposed to prof. In part, this is due to a misreading of hegel and tocqueville, two. Social theory, social research, and a theory of action. Mill, weber, and, more recently, george homans and j. Defenders of methodological individualism generally claim that it is an. Hobbes to locke has been republished just before the fiftieth anniversary of its first publication, 1 which might constitute an approximation to a scholars dream of immortality. Macpherson was a political philosopher who placed a genuinely novel interpretation on the history of political thought in the political theory of possessive individualism. It was first clearly articulated by hobbes, who held that it is necessary that we. Indeed mcpherson himself does not fully develop his own thesis due to some needless methodological commit ments. In economics, peoples behavior is explained in terms of rational choices, as. Three theories of individualism usf scholar commons.
The tension between methodological individualism and holism regarding a complete reduction of sociology to psychology does not realize that both the sensitivepsychic facet of reality psychology and the social side sociology reflectthe quantitative meaning of the one and the many. It was, we might say, conceived by hobbes, who held. Her message is the concept of man as a heroic being, with his. A brief list of individualistic stance of hobbes reminds us of way pers observation hobbes so frequently portrayed as the great absolutist, is perhaps the greatest individualist in the history of political thought. Hodgson abstract advocacy of methodological individualism is widespread, especially among economists. The second law of nature lays down that a man must be willing, along with others and in the interests of peace and. It has been suggested that hobbes was a methodological individualist watkins. The first methodological point on which alfred schutz and talcott parsons had different opinions was called by richard grathoff the weberian suggestion. Hobbes, locke, and rousseau james devine in rich capitalist countries, liberal political cultures.
850 1511 1171 420 947 545 1473 745 163 428 1566 1559 1282 905 44 806 370 450 676 1073 802 524 1222 577 914 1409 391 763 94